Liam wrote:
What is the point in complaining as much as you do? Just get on with it. Also you state that “[...] people sending me e-mails [...] and there was a discussion in the discussion board on facebook for 2 months about how confusing and unclear it is.” Does this not sum up your previous observation of “I know that a lot of not so bright people choose to go to design school, because they’re no good in other areas (eg. areas that actually involve intelligent thinking).” I believe this does.
[...] I have found your rants and constant complaining extremely disrespectful and also fucking annoying. You obviously have no idea as to the links between the projects we were given so maybe you are among those few with no ‘intelligent thinking’ as you so nicely put it.
If this is that much of a problem why don’t you just fuck off else where? Not only have you wasted hours of time preaching on deaf ears and making pointless and patronising books you have also built and ever growning bad reputation for being a dick.
Get a fucking life.
Thanks for your response, Liam.
The point in complaining is I suppose the slight hope that things might change. I personally think people should speak up when they're unhappy about something, that´s an integral part of a democratic society and a university is no exception. A side effect of complaining is also that it acts as a vent for frustration that builds up over time. Perhaps this might even be the reason for your response. Feels good, doesn't it? See, it works. Particularly since this is a personal website and blog, it´s a perfect platform for personal rants.
To answer your questions: You are implying that people who feel lost after being given completely nonsensical instructions and tasks are the not so bright ones which I was referring to when I said that art education attracts people that perhaps aren't necessarily suitable for academia. You might have a point here, those students would certainly count to the group who have problems interpreting these briefs (given that they are willing to 'do it right'). However, the reason for misunderstandings is not on the student side here, it´s on the side of the university that provided the brief. Beside the ambiguous writing style, there were some obvious factual errors in this document. A student, regardless how smart or dim, can and should not be expected to make sense of this scrap of paper as it was. The point that I made in the sentence that you quoted was that the person in question claimed that "noone had a problem", which is blatently a lie and just used as a polemic attempt to defeat my point.
Furthermore, you find my rants annoying—fair enough. It´s your free will to read them or let it be. You find my rants disrespectful, this I would ask you to explain further. Disrespectful towards whom—the people whose wages I pay with my fees and who call me and the rest of the class a "pain in the arse"? Disrespectful towards the people who are trying to teach me something that they don't understand themselves? I have the highest respect for people that deserve it. If someone wants to patronise me, they—at least—have to be better and be able to prove this. Otherwise I will treat them the way they treat me.
You are right, I have no (or hardly any) idea as to what the links between the given projects were supposed to be. I couldn't find it in the so called 'lectures' and neither in any material we were given. I call that bad teaching. At the end of a quiz show the answers should be revealed. All I got was questions and the impression that the answers are "somewhere out there" but certainly not in the mind of the tutors in regards to this particular module. You may call this a teaching style, but for the money I pay, I'd expect more than this—at least that the teacher has an answer that I can compare my own solution to.
And finally: Why don't I fuck off elsewhere? Well, guess what—that was on my mind more than once. I am grateful for the opportunity to go away for a semester and see how things are being run in other places. Perhaps it´s the same story elsewhere, maybe I'll get some ideas that I can feed back to the tutors at UWE, or perhaps it will be worse there and I can appreciate what I've got here. I don't consider running away or 'fucking off'—as you so nicely put it—a solution for anything. It was on my mind as a possible consequence if worst comes worst and when nothing actually changes. I am aware of my options. Don't you worry.
The fact that you and others—and not only students—have read and responded to this blog is an indication that I have not wasted hours (it´s hardly hours to be honest with you) preaching on deaf ears but a sign that raising issues can perpetuate debate, discussion and—if we all keep praying—initiate change.
But as long as you're happy with the situation, I apologise for disturbing your peace. By the way, the only remotely patronising book I can think of is the 'Typo' one, which generated—without exception—very positive responses throughout, from fellow students as well as tutors and lecturers. A fact that even surprised me.
Again, thanks for your response. I appreciate debate.